PDA

View Full Version : What if .... ?



yog
01-22-2002, 12:00 AM
This is an old martial arts adage that cropped up reciently on the MBC forum and was bought home to me again today.



I was in the office most of the day, but at short notice I had to go and visit a derelict farm yard. It was whilst I was stomping around the farms debris littered yard that I began asking myself "what if so and so happened ?" (I have an active imagination). I then began to realise that although my office knife (a standard) would cope with most jobs, in these rugged areas a different knife might have been better.



After coming to this realisation I thought that some other advice given for self defence on the MBC might also be aplicable to daily carry where your not sure what environment / situation you might end up in. The advice was to carry one sheeple freindly knife and one knife of a more serious nature.

It's obvious, but sometimes the obvious gets overlooked. I'd been guilty of carrying a knife to suit the chores I thought I would be doing, rather than for the situations that fate might throw at me.



This led me to start thinking what my ideal "more serious knife" would be. Even though I love my Military dearly I have come to really like leaf shaped blades, the tip feals a lot stronger.



For it's agressive cutting ability the steel would be CPM-440v (although BG-42 is becoming a favourite).



After much thought I settled on plain edge. I had thought seriously of a Spyder edge for it's ability to get in and start cutting quickly, but with more thought I felt that in an emergency situation cloths may need to be cut away from a damaged limb and depending on the material a spyder edge may tend to snag.



Flat ground of course. Hollow ground may be better for light work, but IMHO flat ground is the better all rounder.



Does such a knife exist ?

Well from what I've seen the Lil' Temperance looks pretty darn close, can't wait to get one.



"Walk softly, but carry a big stick."

nomaded
01-22-2002, 05:40 PM
From your specifications, I would definitely suggest the spear-point Lil' Temperance.

Your other choices are possibly a drop-point Moran, or the FB Temperance, but these two are a bit larger than something you would want to carry in an office environment.

Another folder suggestion might be the Lum Chinese Folder.

Just some ideas...

Brandon
01-22-2002, 07:13 PM
Lum chinese definately fits your bill but also the smaller salsa would pretty much cover both areas. it's small but not real small and it feels like a much bigger knife plus it comes in sheeple friendly colors and has a compression lock

Brandon
01-22-2002, 07:22 PM
actually another knife in a different price range (not trying to offend anyone by mentioning a competitor just putting out information) is the Microtech Amphibian. meets almost all of your requirements but in a more powerful recurve blade

ruxton
01-23-2002, 04:52 AM
how about a full size calypso, a formidable knife in plainedge, every bit as sexy as a calypso jr but with extra length.
i would humbly suggest the new plain edged VG-10 harpy, fits just about none of your criteria but it really is gonna be a great knife, with the aggressive hook blade u'll have no trouble with seatbelts or rope etc and it makes a truly evil self defence knife.
inside the old legal blade length in the uk too
MAT